Episode Transcript

Leveraged Investments
Episode 6: January 23, 2007

Hello and welcome to Money Girl’s Quick and Dirty Tips for a Richer Life.

Today’s topic is leverage.

This is one of my favorite financial topics and here’s why: Leverage can turn an ordinary income and savings into real wealth. It’s the key behind the fortunes of many millionaires.

So what is leverage and how can you use it to take control of your financial future? Leverage means using a lever. It’s the power to lift something really heavy with a relatively small effort. When it comes to money, it means using borrowed money and a relatively small initial investment to control a much larger asset.

So what types of investments allow you to use leverage? Well, real estate is one of them. It’s possible to invest in a home using a very high degree of leverage or OPM: other people’s money. This means that, over the long term, you get the benefit of appreciation on the full value of the house, but most of the money used to buy it is the lender’s not yours. This is one of the biggest benefits of investing in real estate. For short term investors, however, it’s also one of the biggest risks.

Although home price appreciation has slowed(1) nationally, over the long term, real estate has appreciated about 5% to 6% per year on average in the U.S. Now this return may not sound like anything to write home about, but the power of leverage can really magnify it.

Let’s look at a simple example: Imagine you buy a house for $100,000 and put $20,000 down (that’s 5:1 leverage). If the house appreciates 5% in the first year, you’ve earned $5,000 on your $20,000 investment from the appreciation—that’s a 25% return (not accounting for closing costs). It’s an impressive return. If you put only $10,000 down (that is, if you use 10:1 leverage) instead, your return from the appreciation doubles to 50%. Now, that’s an amazing return! This example is very simple to illustrate the point. It doesn’t account for net rental income if the house were rented. Assuming the house were rented and generated a positive cash flow, the returns would be even better.

Simply put, leverage can create millionaire returns. With leverage, you can create wealth much more quickly than you could if you paid all cash for a property. If you bought the same $100,000 house for all cash, your return, based solely on that 5% appreciation, would be, of course, 5%. By putting 10% down, instead, the return is boosted 10 times to 50%.

In the U.S., it’s not unusual to put as little as 10% down with the lender financing the remaining 90%, even on a house purchased as an investment. With stocks, the highest leverage you can get is typically 50%, which means you can buy stocks at half their price with the brokerage house supplying the rest of the funds.

Using borrowed money to purchase stocks is called “buying on margin”. But you got to be really careful! It can be very risky! With stocks, you can get a “margin call” if the stock falls below a certain amount. A margin call means the brokerage house can demand that you deposit more money or securities into your account to cover a specified amount of the cost of the stocks bought with borrowed money. A margin call can force you to sell a stock at a very bad time!

With real estate, there is no margin call. If the value drops for a period, even to an amount lower than the balance on the mortgage, the lender doesn’t “call” the loan and expect you to suddenly pay it back. This is a good thing.

Using leverage to purchase real estate can magnify your returns, but it’s really important to remember that it can magnify losses as well. If you put 10% down on a house and the house drops 10% in value, on paper, you’ve lost your entire down payment. And when you factor in, say, 6% in realtor commissions, a drop of only 4% would erase your down payment if you were to sell. But, if you hold for the long term, the downside risk of using leverage when buying real estate is reduced a lot, since U.S. real estate has appreciated over the long term and outpaced inflation.

Now, Money Girl wishes she had known a little more about the power of leverage when she bought her first house. I put 20% down. Had I put 10% down instead, my monthly payments would have been higher, but I would have had the remaining 10% cash to cover that incremental additional payment for many years with money left over to invest in something else.

The power of leverage is the reason that real estate, wisely purchased and held for the long term, can be a powerful strategy to build wealth.

This week, we have a book give-away. Here’s how it works: If you sent me an email or posted to the blog in the Money Girl section of quickanddirtytips.com, you’re automatically entered in the book give-away. This week, the winner is… Amber P. Congratulations, Amber! Please check your email for instructions. You’ve won Investing in Real Estate by Andrew McLean and Gary Eldred, an excellent book on real estate investing with a great explanation of the concept of leverage.

Cha-ching! That's all for now, courtesy of Money Girl, your guide to a richer life.

If you have a question or comment, email it to money@quickanddirtytips.com. Also, check out the other Quick and Dirty Tips podcasts: Grammar Girl, Mr. Manners, and The Traveling Avatar. Thanks for listening!

(1) U.S. home prices increased 0.86% in the third quarter of 2006 (the most recent quarter for which data is available) according to the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight (OFHEO).

 


Comments (19) for Leveraged Investments |  Subscribe to Comment

yuu Says:
5/6/2008 10:38:45 PM
I am Japanese.Englishis ver difficult!
Tony H Says:
5/1/2007 3:38:40 PM
I quite happy with your article & reply to comment regarding investing leverage but I presumed it is only fundamental.

I would like to know in detail calculation of leverage (assumed property is rented) by taking into account of all cost associated and interest/tax deduction. what is the expected or real return for a specified investment with a specific time frame? What is the tax implication?And the amount of tax can be recovered? what is the break-even return on investment.

Your clear explanation to above question is appreciated.
Lily Says:
3/28/2007 10:44:02 PM
When I bought my house, I put 20% down simply to avoid the additional cost of mortgage insurance that would have been required by the lender.

I certainly understand the power of real estate as my father invested and retired at 50, lives solely on the rental income generated. However, it can be a tricky business in some markets and, now that I own a property management business, I know that the wrong renters can make it a very hard proposition.

Thanks for the show!

PS It looks like some of your commenters need to check out Mr. Manners!
Money Girl Says:
2/16/2007 7:28:34 PM
Thanks, Grammar Girl! And thanks, everyone, for your patience while I was away.
Money Girl Says:
2/16/2007 7:26:30 PM
Thanks for the question. Saving for a college education is definitely on my list of topics for upcoming episodes.

To Your Success!
-Money Girl
Money Girl Says:
2/16/2007 5:15:08 PM
Hi Aseem, Missy, Sara, and John! Thanks for being so patient.

The simple example in the episode is based solely on appreciation to illustrate the effects of leverage and doesn’t factor in the expenses of personally living in the property (such as mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, and repairs, for example). The calculation was solely figuring your return on your initial down payment from appreciation alone.

If you did want to factor your housing expenses into the calculation, you’re on the right track, Aseem. If you are living in the house yourself, the calculation tells you whether you are paying to live in your house or whether your house is paying you for the honor of your presence! The calculation is:

Annual Return on Initial Down Payment = (Annual Net Expenses or Net Rental Income If Rented + Annual Appreciation)/Down Payment

To “get paid” to live in your own house, the amount of the annual appreciation would need to be higher than your net expenses for the year. As John correctly points out, your mortgage interest is tax deductible. As a homeowner, your property taxes are deductible as well.

If your house isn’t paying you to live there, don’t feel bad! The important thing to keep in mind is that if you weren’t living in a home of your own, you’d most likely be renting somewhere else. You’d still have a monthly housing expense, but wouldn’t get the long-term benefit of the appreciation.

The table below shows how the return on the initial down payment changes with increasing leverage assuming 5% appreciation, a property value of $100,000, net annual rental income of $4,000, and a mortgage interest rate of 5%. This table takes into account the effect of having a higher mortgage interest expense if you leverage more.




This isn’t exactly “Quick and Dirty,” but it’s still very simplistic. For more details on calculating return on investment for real estate, a really helpful book is "Investing in Real Estate" by McLean and Eldred (available in the sidebar of this webpage).

Also, see my response to Adam below for some of the things to consider when thinking about making a larger versus a smaller down payment when purchasing real estate.

To Your Success!
-Money Girl
Money Girl Says:
2/16/2007 4:10:32 PM
Hi Adam,

The answer depends on your situation. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. Some people like to make a small down payment to keep more of their cash available for other uses, like investing or cash reserves. If you adopt a strategy of making a small down payment, it’s important to be disciplined and invest (rather than spend) the money that would have otherwise gone into making a larger down payment. Depending on how you invest the money, you might make more or less interest than the interest rate on your mortgage. Of course, the goal would be to make more!

One thing to keep in mind is that the mortgage interest on your home is tax deductible, so if the interest rate were, say 8%, and you were in a 25% tax bracket, the effective interest rate would be 6% after factoring in the tax benefit.

To Your Success!

-Money Girl
Grammar Girl Says:
2/15/2007 7:49:25 PM
I'll say it again: Money Girl has been out of town. (She recorded her last few episodes before she left.) I believe she's back now and will answer shortly.
John Says:
2/15/2007 7:33:19 PM
Looks Like Money Girl doesn't care about the comments she gets on her blog.
aseem Says:
2/15/2007 2:20:40 PM
This is strange. Apparently, no one can clarify or explain my post originally posted on 1/24/2007.
Laurel Says:
2/14/2007 12:16:56 PM
I love this podcast, I only wish it were longer, and more frequent! Mostly I am posting because I want to be entered to win one of the books that you give away! Please, oh please. :) Oh, and one more thing: Why use the diminutive word for female: "Money Girl", instead of "Money-Woman"? I realize you want continuity with the other "0000-Girl" podcasts, such as "Grammer-Girl". But I think "Money-Woman and "Grammer-Woman" kind of have a ring to them...they sound like superhero characters while simultaneously embracing adulthood! Thanks for this great podcast.
Laurel
Adam Says:
2/6/2007 7:12:31 PM
"Now, Money Girl wishes she had known a little more about the power of leverage when she bought her first house. I put 20% down. Had I put 10% down instead, my monthly payments would have been higher, but I would have had the remaining 10% cash to cover that incremental additional payment for many years with money left over to invest in something else."

Is this true for any mortgage? If I buy a new house, should I put down as little as possible and use the cash to make the higher payments? Wouldn't I be making less interest than I would be saving by putting more $ into the house?

But I do like the idea of not worrying about payments for a couple of years by using the cash instead.

Can you possibly go further into this strategy and clarify these few points.

Thank you.
John Says:
2/1/2007 4:11:54 PM
Please respond to number 1's question. The reason I came to your website is because I thought the math on your example was a bit simple and did not account for interest or maintenance costs. The one thing #1 did not take into account is the fact that the interest is tax deductible so you would get some of that back.

Do you personally think real estate a good investment right now? Would it make more sense to pay back high interest debt and/or invest in the market?

I love the podcast. Keep up the good work.
Grammar Girl Says:
1/31/2007 9:41:05 PM
Money Girl is away right now; I'm sure she'll answer your questions when she returns.
aseem Says:
1/31/2007 9:06:46 PM
Haven't heard anything from money guru yet. Does she respond to inquiries like the one i made on 24-jan-2007?
sara Says:
1/31/2007 8:44:04 PM
I would like to know the response to Aseem's question too.
Amy H Says:
1/30/2007 3:56:33 PM
Hi Money Girl! I love your podcast! I was hoping you shed some light on 529 plans for me.
missy Says:
1/25/2007 3:20:04 AM
you beat me aseem, i was wondering the same....
Aseem Says:
1/24/2007 4:08:27 PM
I would like some clarification on one of your examples, using a $20000 down payment with 5% appreciation of value on the $100000 property. If I assume that I borrow at 5% from the bank I would have to pay $4000 in interest expense that year. Hence, my returns would only net me ($5000-$4000)=1000.00. $1000.00 return on my $20000.00 investment would only give a 1000/20000=5% increase. I would assume that is 5% number would closer to perhaps 1% or 2% after deducting property taxes, maintenance and so forth.

Am I making a mistake in my calculations?

Add Comment

 *
 *
 *
  Image to deter spam submissions
  To deter spam submissions, please type the letters from the image into the box below:
 *
 
  Fields marked with "*" are required